Primary links

  • About Us
    • Rationale
    • Testimonials
    • People
      • Directors
      • Staff and Fellows
      • Advisors
    • Partners
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Our Work
    • Fellows
    • Progressive Ideas Network
    • Progressive Roundtable
    • Training
      • Talking Politics
    • Research & Strategy
  • Library
    • Our Archive
      • Reports
      • Multimedia
      • Archive Search
    • Other Resources
      • Talking Politics Resources
      • Progressive Infrastructure
  • Press Room
    • Speakers Bureau
    • Press Releases
  • Events
    • Calendar Archive
  • Blog
  • Take Action
    • Get Informed
      • Recommended
      • Spotlight
    • Get Involved
    • Be Influential
      • Ask Kate
  • Donate
Home Blogs Paul Sheldon's blog


Shop for Change!

The Commonweal Collection


Commonweal Institute Bookshelf at Powell's Bookstore

About

The Commonweal Institute is an alliance of independent thinkers leading conversations in media outlets and social networks about American values and progressive approaches to problem-solving.


Financial Crisis Tracker

Become a Fan on Facebook!

Recent Blog Posts

  • UCubed - Union of the Unemployed
  • What if Progressive Activists Acted more like Corporate Lobbyists?
  • Sorry, Obama, you get a “C”
  • Taxes: Let’s Just Go Back To A Simpler Time
  • Defusing Anti-Government Rhetoric
  • The Public Option’s Potent Political Logic
  • Energy Efficiency is the Solution, Not Coal
  • White House Garden Won't Make Up for Obama's Nomination of Pesticide Lobbyist for US Chief Agriculture Negotiator
  • Steps toward Making Women's Economic Power and Security Key Policy Goals
  • A Farewell To Pajamas
more

Subscribe

Front Page RSS Feed

Blog RSS Feed

Blog Archive

Visit our Blog Archive to read posts from from October 2006 to August 2008.

Links

Commonweal Institute

Center for American Progress

Drum Major Institute for Public Policy

Media Matters

Demos

Think Progress

Economic Policy Institute

California Teachers Association

New Progressive Coalition

Speak Out California! - Weblog

FRAMESHOP by Jeffrey Feldman

Two Steps Forward

OnTheCommons.org

Noah Today

By Paul Sheldon, Advisor      October 18, 2008

Topic: Framing

There's a cute .pps circulating, called "Noah today," with spectacular photos of gathering storms. Actually, this presentation represents thinking that originated with the Heritage Foundation, intended to undermine people's support for government regulations.

Leonard Salle (may G-d rest his soul), politely reprimanded me for circulating a previous version that was about all the things we used to do "back in the day" that didn't need regulation or safety protections.

If you read behind the lines, these messages undermine unions, environmental laws, the Americans for Disabilities Act, civil rights, public interest law, disenfranchised communities, and many other forms of socially-agreed-upon consensus -- shared values we need for regulations of all kinds.

In some versions, it even undermines the Bureau of Weights and Measures, that provides verification of honest gallons of gas, ounces, or meat, etc.

As well-intentioned as it may be to distribute this as humor, it's not at all in keeping with the work of True Cost Pricing, which will require all kinds of consensus and regulation. Rather, this piece sabotages shared consensus and majority rule of any kind, dating back to Rousseau, the Polis, and beyond.

In this post-Reagan-Bush era, when Presidential debates ignore the most important issues and return to old, disproven, rote discussions of "Trickle Down" Reaganomics, we need to be ever-vigilant lest we succumb to the kinds of naive thinking that got us into the mess we're trying to clean up.

Paul

  • Paul Sheldon's blog
  • Login to post comments
  • Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

HOME     CONTACT     GET UPDATES     DONATE     LOG IN


COMMONWEAL INSTITUTE
150 Erica Way, Portola Valley, CA 94028
Telephone 650-854-5695
info AT commonwealinstitute DOT org